بِسْمِ اللهِ الرَّحْمٰنِ الرَّحِيمِNew book. Mūsā: The Interlocutor of God, by Shaykh Azhar Nasser.Learn more

Faith and modernity

How liberalism is shaping our children’s faith

What ten years in a Shia school reveal about modernity: why quoting a fatwa no longer persuades, where a young person’s worldview really begins, and which God they are being taught to love.

أَرَأَيْتَ مَنِ اتَّخَذَ إِلَٰهَهُ هَوَاهُ أَفَأَنْتَ تَكُونُ عَلَيْهِ وَكِيلًا

“Have you seen the one who takes his own desire as his god? Would you then be his keeper?”

Qur’an 25:43

Most of our young people could not define liberalism. They live by it all the same. It shapes what they believe freedom is, what they believe fairness is, and who they believe has the right to tell them anything at all.

For nearly ten years I worked directly with the students of Al-Sadiq Islamic School in Toronto, about half of that time as its religious director. It is one of the largest Shia schools in North America: 800 students, and more than a thousand parents I spoke with almost daily. I have served this community for twenty-two years. When I was invited to speak at the God in the Modern World conference, I set the academic paper aside. What I wanted to offer was pastoral: what those years taught me about faith in our time.

I begin with a warning the Prophet ﷺ gave his companion ʿAbd Allāh ibn Masʿūd.

يَا ابْنَ مَسْعُودٍ، يَأْتِي عَلَى النَّاسِ زَمَانٌ الصَّابِرُ عَلَى دِينِهِ مِثْلُ الْقَابِضِ عَلَى الْجَمْرَةِ بِكَفِّهِ

“O Ibn Masʿūd, a time will come upon the people when the one who holds patiently to his religion will be like one who grips a burning coal in his palm.”

The Prophet ﷺ · al-Tabrisi, Makarim al-Akhlaq

In such a time, religion becomes hard to hold. That saying sent me back to a question I had lived with for a decade: why is it so hard, and what exactly is burning our hands?

Ideals and realities

Every religion can be described in two ways. There are its ideals: what a pious Muslim looks like, what correct belief and practice require, what the textual tradition asks of us. These are the concern of the theologian and the jurist. Then there are its realities: what people actually believe, and what they actually do. These are the concern of the ethnographer and the anthropologist of religion.

For ten years I stood in the gap between the two. I knew the books. I also knew the children in front of me, and the books and the children were not always speaking to each other.

The gap rarely looks like open rebellion. It looks like a clash of instincts. On one side is a commitment to autonomy, to the self as the final judge. On the other is a commitment to an organised, scripture-based religion whose authority lies outside the self.

I heard it constantly at school: boys and girls can’t play sports together “because the Shaykh said so.” In the students’ minds, God had dropped out of the sentence. All that remained was a man in a turban restricting their freedom. In staff meetings I kept repeating the same correction. This is not about what the man in this dress allows. It is about a deeper commitment to God.

The orthodoxy no one names

In The Clash of Orthodoxies, the legal philosopher Robert George observes that liberalism rejects any authority lying outside the individual, or outside what the collective self deems reasonable. That is exactly the clash I watched in our classrooms.

Two orthodoxies meet in our community. One is the tradition, with all of its allowances, represented in the Twelver Shia world by the marjaʿiyya. The other is what I call New Age liberalism. The second is so ubiquitous that it is never named. It holds the place Christianity once held in Western societies before the Second World War: it shaped so much of social life that no one needed to define it.

Liberalism is no longer the elephant in the room. Most non-Muslims, and many Muslims, simply live inside it without noticing.

We cannot understand our youth unless we understand the philosophies that shape how they see the world and themselves, even when they cannot name those philosophies. Shahīd Muṭahharī made the point decades ago, in lectures translated into Arabic as al-Imdād al-ghaybī fī ḥayāt al-bashar: every person builds a worldview from a foundational point of departure.

So when a young person sat across from me and said Islam felt too limiting, about a girlfriend or a boyfriend or anything else, I did not open a risāla ʿamaliyya and recite a ruling. I asked where they were starting from. Then I asked their parents the same question. Most of them looked at me blankly. We have absorbed liberalism so completely that we no longer see it.

Where the idea came from

None of this fell from the sky. In tracing it, I owe a great deal to two thinkers: Dr. Sherman Abdul Hakim Jackson, whom I came to know when he was a visiting professor at McMaster University, and the Catholic philosopher Charles Taylor, whom I know only through his books.

The movement of the seventeenth and eighteenth centuries began as a rejection of the Church: first the Catholic Church, then any institutional religious authority at all. Kant gave it a motto: have the courage to use your own reason. What began as a fringe academic position did not stay at the fringe. As Taylor shows in The Malaise of Modernity, his Massey Lectures, such ideas slowly reshaped the whole ecosystem of Western social and religious life. Its prophets, if we can call them that, were Kant, Nietzsche, Derrida and Foucault.

The result, after 1950, was a new idea of authenticity and fulfilment. It is human-centred and self-determining. It is not rooted in a metaphysical order in which beauty begins with God, who therefore decides what is authentic and what is beautiful.

إِنَّ اللَّهَ جَمِيلٌ يُحِبُّ الْجَمَالَ، وَيُحِبُّ أَنْ يَرَى أَثَرَ النِّعْمَةِ عَلَى عَبْدِهِ

“God is beautiful and loves beauty, and He loves to see the trace of His blessing on His servant.”

Imam ʿAli · al-Kulayni, al-Kafi, vol. 6, p. 438, no. 1

Where faith survives inside the modern frame, it survives on its terms: to each their own, my God and your God.

Rousseau could describe morality as following the voice of nature within us. Our children hear versions of that sentence for eight hours a day at school, then again at university, and they learn to treat its authors as near-prophetic figures. What they absorb, to borrow from Taylor’s A Secular Age, is an unlimited pluralism within the limits of a political order.

When the verse was not enough

How does this play out? Over ten years I watched ideas that were once unthinkable to Shia and Muslim consciousness move from the margins to the centre. I say this not about any one school. It is our community, and our society, as a whole.

One year, a brother came to me, alarmed. In a Sunday school class, questions of sexuality and identity had come up, and the teacher, who was not qualified to handle them, had answered with little more than “we love everyone.” Sixteen- and seventeen-year-olds were now fully on board. So I met the students myself.

I was naive then, a man who lived in his books. I came in with the heavy artillery: this verse, that narration. “Say: if you love God, follow me, and God will love you and forgive you your sins” (Qur’an 3:31). I truly believed that would be enough.

It was not. The room went quiet. Afterwards I learned how it had landed: there is so much hate in the world, the students felt, and we simply have to love everyone. About three-quarters of the class held their position. The group was oppressed, so we must stand with them. That day I learned the difference between ideals and realities, between the books and the people.

The second pattern was harder still. When I began this work, the troubling reports I heard about sexual activity concerned fifteen- and sixteen-year-olds. Year after year the age dropped. I began to hear of ten- and eleven-year-olds experimenting, of eleven-year-olds watching pornography.

We have the best religion, I kept telling myself. We have scholars, books, ijāzas and fiery sermons. And yet. Perhaps those of us in turbans, myself first among them, have not been doing the right job.

Fifty pages before wuḍūʾ

Around that time I met Dr. Jackson. The department at McMaster had called me: they had brought in a visiting professor, and nobody had signed up to meet him. I did not yet know who he was. We ended up spending two or three days together, and over a cheesesteak I asked him what I had been asking myself for years: how do you raise children in today’s world? His answer reframed my decade.

“Brother, you’re looking at it the wrong way. You’re treating the symptom. You have to understand their point of departure, the core of their heart and their mind.”

Dr. Sherman Abdul Hakim Jackson

He told me he had written a book for his sixteen-year-old daughter. They were now on the rules of wuḍūʾ. But the first fifty pages were about the pitfalls of neoliberalism. With those in place, he said, he was not worried about the rest. The rulings would fit, because she would have a point of departure of her own, and she would see how empty a pluralism without limits really is.

I should not misrepresent him. Dr. Jackson has written at length on what he calls the Islamic secular, and he does not argue that Islam simply rejects secularity. His point to me was narrower and sharper: rulings land only on a foundation, and our children’s foundation was being laid by someone else.

The Imams saw this long before us. Imam al-Ṣādiq (ʿa) told the believers of his own day not to wait.

بَادِرُوا أَوْلَادَكُمْ بِالْحَدِيثِ قَبْلَ أَنْ يَسْبِقَكُمْ إِلَيْهِمُ الْمُرْجِئَةُ

“Hasten to teach your children hadith, before the Murjiʾa reach them first.”

Imam al-Sadiq · al-Kulayni, al-Kafi, vol. 6, p. 47, no. 5

The Murjiʾa taught a faith that asked nothing of a person’s deeds. Every age has its version of that message. Someone will reach our children first; it should be us.

So I readjusted. I read Charles Taylor, Gai Eaton, William Chittick, Seyyed Hossein Nasr and Dr. Jackson’s own work. They differ from one another in important ways, but together they taught me to look for root causes where I had been seeing only symptoms.

Which God are we worshipping?

We often complain that young people are apathetic, even indifferent, towards the ʿulamāʾ. I remember a Ramadan night at a masjid in Chicago. After the prayer, only a handful of men came forward to greet the shaykh; everyone else hurried off. He turned to the fathers and said: if you had taught your children to respect the scholars, they would have come.

He was right, but that indifference has a source. It is deeply rooted, and it has causes. Beneath it lies a deeper question: what is the God worshipped by such a person? What does that God look like?

The Catholic theologian Ulrich Lehner wrote a provocative book called God Is Not Nice. In its introduction he warns against the vending-machine God: put in your coins, or your prayers, and collect what you wanted. This is religion without responsibility and without consequences. Its God loves you unconditionally, however selective and self-centred your worship becomes. Worship of that God transforms nothing. It does not unsettle us. It serves us.

That is not the God of the Qur’an and the Sunna. When worship is quietly redirected towards a God of convenience, no fatwa, however correct, will hold. Every ruling assumes a Lord who has the right to command. Our children need to know Him before they can hear His law.

أَوَّلُ الدِّينِ مَعْرِفَتُهُ

“The beginning of religion is knowing Him.”

Imam ʿAli · Nahj al-Balagha, Sermon 1

Five questions for parents, teachers and the young

The conference asked about God in the modern world. My answer is that we must stop treating symptoms and start contemplating root causes. That is where the study of our intellectual tradition, the history of ideas, becomes indispensable.

الْعَالِمُ بِزَمَانِهِ لَا تَهْجُمُ عَلَيْهِ اللَّوَابِسُ

“One who understands his time is not overrun by its confusions.”

Imam al-Sadiq · al-Kulayni, al-Kafi, vol. 1, Kitab al-ʿAql wa al-Jahl

Begin with five questions.

  1. What is my point of departure?

    Name the assumptions you start from before you argue about conclusions.

  2. Who has authority over me, and why?

    Notice when “the Shaykh said” has quietly replaced “God commands.”

  3. Which ideas have I absorbed without choosing them?

    Schools, screens, hospitals and politics all teach a worldview; few of them announce it.

  4. Am I answering the person, or only the symptom?

    A ruling recited to a heart that has not met its Lord rarely lands.

  5. What kind of God do I worship?

    One who serves my wishes, or the One before whom my wishes are weighed?

Then ask the question that matters most: when the coal burns, what will keep you holding it? If the answer is not God Himself, begin there.

Study these questions further

Every ruling assumes a Lord, and every point of departure begins with Him. God and His Attributes, the first course every Tasneem student takes, starts there: twenty-five lessons with Shaykh Azhar Nasser on the Qur’anic conception of God, His attributes, and the ways He deals with His creation.